Closing threads is not an approach that I like. It should be suitable for Mods to nip certain activities in the bud. Thread closing smells fairly autocratic, and I think it happens more often than it should, probably by several-fold.
Other opinions?
Printable View
Closing threads is not an approach that I like. It should be suitable for Mods to nip certain activities in the bud. Thread closing smells fairly autocratic, and I think it happens more often than it should, probably by several-fold.
Other opinions?
I don't see it happening that much, but a few threads on current topics like Apple closing more doors, could have been better served by cleaning it up rather than locking it up. I've come across a few new articles and information pieces that would fit into there.
On the other hand, its easy on the mods to lock and move on, and if the subject is that important or evolving, I don't see the issue in creating a new thread thats trying a little harder. At least for news worthy topics.
Once things get to the point of needing to be cleaned up or closed, the tone is rarely going to improve. We've repeatedly demonstrated that. Closing seems like the proper response.
Is there a reason the "Ireland to go bust" thread was closed?
:confused:
I think someone clicked the wrong button when submitting their reply. :noob:
That would be my guess.
I don't agree with you guys. I think a number of threads were closed when things hadn't gotten bad at all. I'd call it zero tolerance of criticism for the management, not justified closings. If things has gotten really ugly, including speculation on the source of pustules on other members' genitalia, then yeah, close it. If somebody is fussing about a mod's actions, things haven't gone too far. Saying they have and closing the thread is fairly authoritarian.
Except I don't see any criticism of mod actions in that thread...
Just seen this thread, it's very rare for me to lock a thread and I think its even rarer if ever for it to be due to a "criticism of management". I'm notoriously thick skinned and I think Dread is the same and Wraith will be too.
I think the Ireland thread was an accident so I've unlocked it.
Give Dread a WL so we can watch his reaction. :up: :D
Fight the POWER! :mad:Quote:
Originally Posted by RandBlade
Tsk, FIFA thread. :oQuote:
Originally Posted by RandBlade
Accident
You guys have had a lot of 'accidents' lately
Should your girlfriends be worried?
Meaning that past performance is not a predictor of future performance? I'm complaining about a pronounced authoritarian streak here, as well as a pronounced lack of transparency.Quote:
Originally Posted by RandBlade
Authoritarian streak meaning accidentally locking two threads for a few hours? Seriously? :bored: Or do you mean handing our all those warnings? Or more likely, is it that moderators say mean things to you in their non-mod capacity?
I don't understand what sort of hippie commune you'd want us to be. The moderators, insofar as I've seen, have not locked threads that did not warrant locking (intentionally), are extremely lenient about warnings, and very very rarely disrupt conversation no matter how heated. What more do you want? Everyone to be mods? That'd be a fine afternoon before we'd all be banned.Quote:
Originally Posted by ']['ear
That brings back some IRC memories from middle school. :haha:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nessus
No, what I really want is for you to walk around and fucking troll me in every thread. Could I have that? Please? Could I? Oh, wait! I do!Quote:
Originally Posted by Loki
Fucking wanker.
Any particular reason why it was necessary to respond to this 5 days later? I think you and your mates successfully drove Icky away, anyway. Congratulations, I guess.Quote:
Originally Posted by ']['ear
Mods, I think the time has come to close this thread. :|
<Mod hat>Quote:
Originally Posted by ']['ear
Warning for excessive stupidity. This was arguably trolling, but it's undeniably stupid. You've also had somewhat similar behavior in another thread, and I'll address it there. But this thread is closed.
</Mod hat>