Originally Posted by
Kazuha Vinland
Just will throw in a torch here. I am familiar with a psychiatrist that works with heavily disabled children here, where one of the methods is physically restraining them when they hurt themselves, just like a dog therapy where the dog is forced down and immobilized when having a serious fit. While this might seem incredibly inhumane, the effects this has on dogs, and likewise human with certain kinds of mental disabilities, appeared to be remarkably positive compared to other treatments. They had in common that the parents of these children, also supported this kind of behavioral treatment, even though doing so to a functionally well human, would be seen as literal torture. But the thing is, there has so far not in these few cases, not been alternative treatment for these kind of mental illnesses, other than strong sedatives that largely impede the life quality of the patients. The parents have spent their ENTIRE lives, many of them with "children" well into adulthood, where they are simply miserable. After having such treatment, although an extreme form, they see the near immediate positive effects on behavior and their happiness generally being improved by a lot. Yes, none of the patients enjoy their pain there and then, but that is sort of also the point - that you have brain modulation, that after a short while, rewires them to stop self hurting for instance. I do not for a second believe that the people at this facility, consider themselves heartless or evil. I believe they really think they are in the right, and just maybe, they are. The controversial episodes they mentioned, were very obviously malpractice of the episode, which they also fully acknowledged - and had made adjustments and changes thereby. And the one patient that reflected back on his own treatment, might not have been actually mentally ill enough, to warrant such a treatment plan.
I generally think that unless you have worked specifically with that kind of mental illness, one should not be so quick to judge, what would normally be seen as shocking (pun not intended) treatment. For some rare cases, it very well might be the only effective treatment that has made a change, as signed by all those parents who've tried literally everything.