Originally Posted by
Enoch the Red
While I agree with the gist of what you are trying to get across, using obviously bad numbers to refute an obviously bad argument seems pretty silly. Comparing the population of the whole of Georgia to the population of NYC doesn't seem exactly like an apples to apples comparison. Looking at a city like Atlanta might be a better comparison, and there the population density is about 7 times less. Now how the virus spreads and scales with regard to population density is unknown, (though places like Hong Kong seem to have escaped much of the scourge with a similar density) but I think it is fairly safe to say that NYC and likely New York made some fairly serious missteps early on in their handling of the pandemic. Some of those probably could have been avoided, some of those were likely due to incomplete or incorrect information, but to use an univariate analysis for pandemic spread, let alone an analysis where your only variable is population density, seems like a fools errand.