Quote Originally Posted by Lewkowski View Post
Who makes the determination? Tread carefully because your answer should be consistent with the previous 200 years and a willingness for the answer to be the same in the next 200 years.
Scientists who study the matter. What is science and what is not is decided not by the results but by how those results are obtained. Just because scientific theories are constantly adjusted to take into account new knowledge says nothing about the scientific nature of those theories. The problem with ID is that it does not use scientific methods. Ergo, it's not scientific. The question isn't over whether it's correct or wrong.