Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 30 of 32

Thread: Jury Duty

  1. #1

    Default Jury Duty

    Anyone here ever serve jury duty on a criminal trial?

    A few weeks ago I did and we ended up convicting on several counts. I felt guilty at first at standing in judgement against someone because, as Jesus has always said, we're all sinners and such.

    But upon finally crawling out of the hole of this long trial, I finally got to research the defendant. And now I found that s/he is suspected in several other un-prosecuted crimes and is also standing trial for still more trials in a neighboring county. Which actually made me feel a lot better.

    Familier experience to anyone here?

  2. #2
    Stingy DM Veldan Rath's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Maine! And yes, we have plumbing!
    Posts
    3,064
    Was on a DUI jury several years back.

    We acquitted.
    Brevior saltare cum deformibus viris est vita

  3. #3
    Senior Member Flixy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,435
    Out of curiosity, what kind of DUI case can get acquitted, don't they do alcohol tests?

  4. #4
    Could have been there was no test done, or other bad evidence...but I'm also curious.

  5. #5
    Stingy DM Veldan Rath's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Maine! And yes, we have plumbing!
    Posts
    3,064
    No test was completed.
    Brevior saltare cum deformibus viris est vita

  6. #6
    I have previous, so won't ever be called up.

  7. #7
    Quote Originally Posted by Veldan Rath View Post
    No test was completed.
    How'd that even reach trial then

    Never been called. I'd find it awkward not to look online nowadays into the defendants background.

    If you don't mind Tim, what kind of previous?
    Quote Originally Posted by Ominous Gamer View Post
    ℬeing upset is understandable, but be upset at yourself for poor planning, not at the world by acting like a spoiled bitch during an interview.

  8. #8
    Probably jury-duty-dodging
    "One day, we shall die. All the other days, we shall live."

  9. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by RandBlade View Post
    How'd that even reach trial then
    Its common to arrest people for suspicion of DUI if the officer doesn't have a testing kit and the driver is unable to complete a field test for whatever reason. An arrest went viral a few weeks ago because a black man was arrested on suspicion and ended up blowing a 0.00, and had to fight the police to get his car back.


    I've been called a couple of times, first time I was released the night before I was supposed to show up, the 2nd time I wasn't picked because of (I assume) my drug stance, and the 3rd time I was excused because I would have missed a monster truck rally I already had tickets for.
    "In a field where an overlooked bug could cost millions, you want people who will speak their minds, even if they’re sometimes obnoxious about it."

  10. #10
    Quote Originally Posted by Ominous Gamer View Post
    Its common to arrest people for suspicion of DUI if the officer doesn't have a testing kit and the driver is unable to complete a field test for whatever reason. An arrest went viral a few weeks ago because a black man was arrested on suspicion and ended up blowing a 0.00, and had to fight the police to get his car back.
    There was one good thing about that incident: we got to read about the Surprise Police Dept.
    "One day, we shall die. All the other days, we shall live."

  11. #11
    Senior Member Flixy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,435
    I think over here they can arrest on suspicion, but if you're not tested at the station there is no case. there's still reckless driving of course, assuming it's your driving style that got their attention in the first place.

    We don't have juries here, btw.

  12. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by Flixy View Post
    I think over here they can arrest on suspicion, but if you're not tested at the station there is no case. there's still reckless driving of course, assuming it's your driving style that got their attention in the first place.
    As far as I'm aware its the same here - though I believe a breathalyser is standard kit in a Police Car. I've been pulled over and breathalysed a few times (always passed of course) and once pulled over by an off duty cop who had a conversation and realised I wasn't drunk - had he thought I was I'd have had to be taken to a station for a test.
    Quote Originally Posted by Ominous Gamer View Post
    ℬeing upset is understandable, but be upset at yourself for poor planning, not at the world by acting like a spoiled bitch during an interview.

  13. #13
    fuck, how bad is your driving?
    "In a field where an overlooked bug could cost millions, you want people who will speak their minds, even if they’re sometimes obnoxious about it."

  14. #14
    I was in a general jury "pool" for a week, a long time ago. That meant waiting in a stuffy jury room, with tons of people, all day, day after day, in crappy folding chairs, waiting to be called for a case selection. It was pretty bad. I had a little baby at the time, but they wouldn't excuse me for Family Hardship.

    They called me for a personal injury/medical malpractice suit but was dismissed for bias. They paid us something like $10/day and reimbursed our parking garage costs.

  15. #15
    Quote Originally Posted by RandBlade View Post
    Never been called. I'd find it awkward not to look online nowadays into the defendants background.
    It was surprisingly easy. The judge also reminded us non-stop. It also helped that we were locked in a courthouse all day except for an hour of lunch, and then most of us had to catch-up on work during the day.

    Quote Originally Posted by Flixy View Post
    We don't have juries here, btw.
    Interesting. While I got some value out of the experience, I wasn't necessarily beaming with pride at the jury system. Then again, the idea of concentrating power in the hands of judges is somewhat scary to me.

    Ireland has juries that are based on a majority vote (here you can only convict if a jury is in complete, unanimous agreement).

    So you have judges decide guilt/innocence?

    Quote Originally Posted by GGT View Post
    I was in a general jury "pool" for a week, a long time ago. That meant waiting in a stuffy jury room, with tons of people, all day, day after day, in crappy folding chairs, waiting to be called for a case selection. It was pretty bad. I had a little baby at the time, but they wouldn't excuse me for Family Hardship.

    They called me for a personal injury/medical malpractice suit but was dismissed for bias. They paid us something like $10/day and reimbursed our parking garage costs.
    Yeah, one of the jurors had her teenage kid in the hallway the whole time because she didn't know where else to put her (not sure why school wasn't an option...).

    Quote Originally Posted by RandBlade View Post
    As far as I'm aware its the same here - though I believe a breathalyser is standard kit in a Police Car. I've been pulled over and breathalysed a few times (always passed of course) and once pulled over by an off duty cop who had a conversation and realised I wasn't drunk - had he thought I was I'd have had to be taken to a station for a test.
    Why pulled over so many times? Canada, watch out!

  16. #16
    Quote Originally Posted by GGT View Post
    I was in a general jury "pool" for a week, a long time ago. That meant waiting in a stuffy jury room, with tons of people, all day, day after day, in crappy folding chairs, waiting to be called for a case selection. It was pretty bad. I had a little baby at the time, but they wouldn't excuse me for Family Hardship.

    They called me for a personal injury/medical malpractice suit but was dismissed for bias. They paid us something like $10/day and reimbursed our parking garage costs.
    Jury duty waiting rooms is an exercise in government failure. I've gone 3 times and only made it to the questioning of jury phase by the lawyer prior to trail once. 3 working days to be part of a pool of 30 and not even selected (not that I wanted to be). How much easier would it be to electronically sign in on-line and then receive a text 1 hour prior? If you don't have a cell phone - fine sit in jury pool but why waste people's day?

  17. #17
    Quote Originally Posted by Ominous Gamer View Post
    fuck, how bad is your driving?
    I used to work til midnight and would then be driving home - random stops of drivers late at night around Christmas time would then mean I was pulled. I estimate I was pulled no more than once a year but I worked those late shifts for 8 years so easy to get a few times.

    Once pulled on day 2 of driving a new car as I had my fog lights on (didn't realise, I thought I'd just turned the headlights on). They helped me adjust the dials until it was correct.

    Once pulled because I'd swerved over the white line on the road (so you could say 'bad driving' for that one), I'd sneezed suddenly.
    Quote Originally Posted by Ominous Gamer View Post
    ℬeing upset is understandable, but be upset at yourself for poor planning, not at the world by acting like a spoiled bitch during an interview.

  18. #18

  19. #19
    Quote Originally Posted by RandBlade View Post
    If you don't mind Tim, what kind of previous?
    Drink driving, in my overly wreckless youth, more than 20 years ago.

    ~£150 fine, 12 month ban, and standing up in court to explain myself to a magistrate. As was standard.

    Licence was cleared after 10 years, as was, I believe, my police record. Regardless, as I understand it, I'll not ever be called for jury duty as a result, so there must remain a record of my conviction retained somewhere despite the police record being expunged.

  20. #20
    It doesn't make much sense to "ban" someone from jury duty because of a DUI. I wonder how many lawyers and judges have the same charges on their record...

    Some US states "ban" convicted felons from jury duty for life, and rescind their voting rights, too. That might make sense if our criminal justice system didn't have whacky definitions of felony crimes.

  21. #21
    As far as I'm aware a DUI bans you for life from being a personal licence holder (needed to sell alcohol eg as a bar manager) or from being a Police Officer.
    Quote Originally Posted by Ominous Gamer View Post
    ℬeing upset is understandable, but be upset at yourself for poor planning, not at the world by acting like a spoiled bitch during an interview.

  22. #22
    Really? How is that working to reduce British alcohol-related crimes?

  23. #23
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Amsterdam/Istanbul
    Posts
    12,462
    Quote Originally Posted by Dreadnaught View Post
    I
    Interesting. While I got some value out of the experience, I wasn't necessarily beaming with pride at the jury system. Then again, the idea of concentrating power in the hands of judges is somewhat scary to me.

    Ireland has juries that are based on a majority vote (here you can only convict if a jury is in complete, unanimous agreement).

    So you have judges decide guilt/innocence?
    Yes, it is a point of some concern for some people, but not many.
    Congratulations America

  24. #24
    Are your judges appointed or elected? Do they have some kind of oversight, or term limits?


    Edit for Dread: what exactly left you feeling a lack of pride in our jury system?

    Maybe I'm reading between the lines too much (and way off-base), but you seemed critical of the jury pool. It's worth noting that our jury pools are drawn from registered voter records.

    Perhaps that's also why you're "scared" of judges---who are either directly elected by voters, or appointed by another elected official---having too much concentrated power without using juries? Judges can also have the power to nullify a jury verdict (I'm not sure if that applies in all states).

    Well, it should come as no surprise that our laws/legislation, police/enforcement, judiciary/punishment is tied together by politicians and voters. That's how our representative democracy and rule of law plays out.

    Personally, it bothers me that a "jury of peers" is becoming meaningless, in practical terms.
    Last edited by GGT; 06-27-2013 at 04:50 AM.

  25. #25
    I did jury duty, one of the last ones in Geneva before they switched to professional jurors. Was an interesting experience, had a hard time explaining to my boss that it could not be taken of my vacation and that if they wished to pay the CHF 1,000 per day fine for me for each day of absence from court I would be happy not to go. The experience itself was interesting and annoying at the same time, the first case concerned a pedophile and the second case concerning a murder committed over 10 years ago and the major decision was to decide whether it was premeditated or not, as if not there would be no conviction as there is prescription.
    I was annoyed that the murders sentence was significantly greater than the pedophile who raped his adopted and natural daughter and there was nothing we could do about it due to maximum/minimum sentences allotted for each crime. It was a little more involved than in US system as the jury gets to decide guilty and not guilty, and then the actual sentence, the judge is only there to insure that we stay within bounds of the law when fixing the sentence.
    I found it curious that the fact that the pedophile was a heavy marijuana user we had to reduce his sentence by law. Felt somewhat upset at convicting the murderer the guy was in his 70s, visually resembled my father and I did not feels he represented any future threat to society, but I was the one that swayed the rest of the jurors that murder was premeditated because his defense was ridiculous and just like that the sentence went from 0 to 18 years. I am sure he appealed I somewhat hope he was successful.
    I felt both lawyers defending the people in question should be disbarred, in particular the guy who defended the pedophile because I am quite convinced they did a disservice to their client. The Pedophiles centered on contesting how many times the girls were violated and arguing the poor conditions for pedophiles in the Swiss incarceration facilities. Result he did not get the clause that would have forced the jurors to reduce the maximum sentence by something like 25% for admitting the crime and I am not sure what was the point of the argument because really raping a 5 year old once or 5 times I don’t see much difference. In essence he admitted the crime but at the same time denied himself the benefits of that admission.
    What annoyed me most and this is sad and selfish, but I am convinced it has to be taken in to account, is the length of the proceedings. We met at early (8 or 9am can’t remember now) and finished late no earlier than 11 pm, once at 1 am (The court goes in to recess at the sole discretion of the judge, apparently I got the 2 judges with no lives). The first hearing took 3 days and the other 4. In both hearings all the facts were sufficiently disclosed in the first half a day, the rest was prosecutor and the lawyer trying to justify their salary and enjoying the sound of their own voice rehashing the same facts over and over again. By the end of the first day I would have been happy to give jail sentence to all involved in dragging out the proceedings, unfortunately not in my power. The jurors are people with lives, their asses hurt from sitting in chair all day with tiny breaks, I don’t understand how a lawyer that was describing the horrors of the Swiss prison in to the early hours of the morning was thinking he was getting sympathy for his clients.

  26. #26
    Senior Member Flixy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,435
    Quote Originally Posted by Dreadnaught View Post
    Interesting. While I got some value out of the experience, I wasn't necessarily beaming with pride at the jury system. Then again, the idea of concentrating power in the hands of judges is somewhat scary to me.

    Ireland has juries that are based on a majority vote (here you can only convict if a jury is in complete, unanimous agreement).

    So you have judges decide guilt/innocence?
    Yeah, if not jurors, who else is there to do that?

    Quote Originally Posted by GGT View Post
    Are your judges appointed or elected? Do they have some kind of oversight, or term limits?
    Appointed, by an independent commission, and appointed for life to increase independence (they aren't pressured to rule one way or the other out of fair to lose their job). The heavier cases have multiple judges, and you claim a judge isn't impartial you can always file for a substitution at any point before or during the proceedings. Also keep in mind that we have civil law, not common law, so decisions have less impact outside the case itself.

    I think the idea is to let cases be determined by people who are professionals and know the law, rather than a group of laymen, and to avoid influence of emotions etc.
    Keep on keepin' the beat alive!

  27. #27
    Quote Originally Posted by GGT View Post
    Are your judges appointed or elected? Do they have some kind of oversight, or term limits?


    Edit for Dread: what exactly left you feeling a lack of pride in our jury system?

    Maybe I'm reading between the lines too much (and way off-base), but you seemed critical of the jury pool. It's worth noting that our jury pools are drawn from registered voter records.

    Perhaps that's also why you're "scared" of judges---who are either directly elected by voters, or appointed by another elected official---having too much concentrated power without using juries? Judges can also have the power to nullify a jury verdict (I'm not sure if that applies in all states).

    Well, it should come as no surprise that our laws/legislation, police/enforcement, judiciary/punishment is tied together by politicians and voters. That's how our representative democracy and rule of law plays out.

    Personally, it bothers me that a "jury of peers" is becoming meaningless, in practical terms.
    You're correct, the jury pool had a few weak links. Overall we had a lot of strong folks who really took the time to review each charge (~10 charges). But I think my unease was just with the idea of standing in judgement of someone, and that someday I could end up being judged by a similar motley crew of people. Which made me super-attentive and careful with every aspect of the trial.

    It also means the decision-making is dumbed-down by the judges to a certain extent, which I imagine is tough for certain types of cases.

    Quote Originally Posted by Asmodian View Post
    I felt both lawyers defending the people in question should be disbarred, in particular the guy who defended the pedophile because I am quite convinced they did a disservice to their client. The Pedophiles centered on contesting how many times the girls were violated and arguing the poor conditions for pedophiles in the Swiss incarceration facilities. Result he did not get the clause that would have forced the jurors to reduce the maximum sentence by something like 25% for admitting the crime and I am not sure what was the point of the argument because really raping a 5 year old once or 5 times I don’t see much difference. In essence he admitted the crime but at the same time denied himself the benefits of that admission.

    What annoyed me most and this is sad and selfish, but I am convinced it has to be taken in to account, is the length of the proceedings. We met at early (8 or 9am can’t remember now) and finished late no earlier than 11 pm, once at 1 am (The court goes in to recess at the sole discretion of the judge, apparently I got the 2 judges with no lives). The first hearing took 3 days and the other 4. In both hearings all the facts were sufficiently disclosed in the first half a day, the rest was prosecutor and the lawyer trying to justify their salary and enjoying the sound of their own voice rehashing the same facts over and over again. By the end of the first day I would have been happy to give jail sentence to all involved in dragging out the proceedings, unfortunately not in my power. The jurors are people with lives, their asses hurt from sitting in chair all day with tiny breaks, I don’t understand how a lawyer that was describing the horrors of the Swiss prison in to the early hours of the morning was thinking he was getting sympathy for his clients.
    I agree, defense lawyers can really fuck things up. These defense lawyers kept contesting minor points of evidence and missing a big hole that one witness had opened up, which potentially invalidated one of the charges. During deliberations I honestly found myself constructing better arguments than the defense on some charges.

    Not sure if this is a plus or minus, but because of our cancerous government unions, each day at court ended precisely at 4:30PM. Then again, the trial probably took a week longer than it needed to.

    Quote Originally Posted by Flixy View Post
    Yeah, if not jurors, who else is there to do that?


    Appointed, by an independent commission, and appointed for life to increase independence (they aren't pressured to rule one way or the other out of fair to lose their job). The heavier cases have multiple judges, and you claim a judge isn't impartial you can always file for a substitution at any point before or during the proceedings. Also keep in mind that we have civil law, not common law, so decisions have less impact outside the case itself.

    I think the idea is to let cases be determined by people who are professionals and know the law, rather than a group of laymen, and to avoid influence of emotions etc.
    I don't know, I thought maybe you elect a committee of nobles to stand in judgement of commoners. Kidding of course.

    It's an interesting judicial difference, and I'm not sure if I lean strongly towards either system but I may have a slight preference for juries because of their relative independence from the world of government (judges may not be subject to political pressures, but they don't exist in a political vacuum).

  28. #28
    Senior Member Flixy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,435
    Quote Originally Posted by Dreadnaught View Post
    I don't know, I thought maybe you elect a committee of nobles to stand in judgement of commoners. Kidding of course.
    Aw, you think commoners even get a trial?
    It's an interesting judicial difference, and I'm not sure if I lean strongly towards either system but I may have a slight preference for juries because of their relative independence from the world of government (judges may not be subject to political pressures, but they don't exist in a political vacuum).
    I'm not really sure which way I lean either. Juries sound, as a principle, better to me. On the other hand, juries aren't in a political or media vacuum either, and a bit more cynical: a lot of people are morons I feel they may be a lot more subjective and have things other than facts influence them - there seem to have been a few cases where the racial breakdown of juries seemed of importance, for example.

    I do think I prefer that our judges are appointed independent from politics, instead of elected or appointed by the ruling party of the time.
    Keep on keepin' the beat alive!

  29. #29
    Quote Originally Posted by Dreadnaught View Post
    You're correct, the jury pool had a few weak links. Overall we had a lot of strong folks who really took the time to review each charge (~10 charges). But I think my unease was just with the idea of standing in judgement of someone, and that someday I could end up being judged by a similar motley crew of people. Which made me super-attentive and careful with every aspect of the trial.
    But it's not really judging "someone" in a personal way, but deciding if the evidence proves they're guilty of a crime (with higher standards for criminal cases). That makes judges' explanations of charges, and the process, really important for juries. And since "lawyering" abilities make a big difference for the accused, especially highly-paid attorneys vs public defenders, those motley crews need good judge guidance, and a decent lead juror.

    I think modern media has dramatically changed our ideas toward crime and punishment, police, forensics, prosecutors, lawyers, trials. Practically everyone has watched crime shows on TV or movies, but even 'real' trials streamed live. (Wasn't it after the OJ trial that Court TV and other cable shows and networks sprung up?) That has certainly changed our expectations of how things should work....but reality is never quite like Law & Order.

  30. #30
    Flixy- Thinking about it more, I guess I am slightly afraid that a political culture could emerge where judges were always picked because of political connections and the justice system simply became a patronage job.

    GGT- You're correct. We had one lawyer on the jury who (in addition to myself) sort of facilitated the deliberations. The lawyer was really good at that and it helped a lot.

    As did the judges instructions, which were slightly confusing to some of us but not everyone.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •